8 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Saunders's avatar

The idea that Jews are child-killers is already deeply embedded in the Western psyche, so the people have been primed, at least unconsciously, to accept it.

Similarly, the genocide accusation is the modern version of the deicide accusation. In both cases, it is the biggest crime that society could possibly imagine, striking against what it holds most sacred (God for Medieval Christians; human rights law and ethnic diversity for modern Westerners).

Mark M's avatar

Six days after October 7th, "Jewish Currents," a left-wing publication which uses the title formerly run by the Communist Party USA, published a 25 page article by a "genocide scholar," Raz Segal, explaining how Israel was committing a genocide in Gaza. Given the length of the article and the date of publication, I have to assume that Segal wrote the article before October 7th, had it on is his computer, touched it up and had it published before Israel had even reacted to the events of October 7th. Incidentally, Segal is employed at a no-name college in New Jersey, was offered the directorship of a Jewish institute at the University of Minnesota, which he lost, when the local donors rose up against his appointment. So there is some small measure of justice in the universe for so-called "scholars."

Brian's avatar

Agreed. To fortify your argument even further: your numbers for the Holocaust and the Rwandan genocide should be even worse for an apples to apples comparison (which only steelmans your point). Of the 9.5 million Jews in Europe, only approx. 7.1 million ever came under the control of the Axis (excludes the UK Jews and the Jews living deeper in the USSR), and of the 1.1 million that weren’t killed in Nazi-occupied Europe, around 500-600k were very close to being killed in Romania and Hungary.

For the Rwandan genocide, the commonly cited figure is 800k deaths, which would lead to at least 75% death toll among the Tutsis.

Again, this only strengthens your argument further and shows the ridiculousness of the “Gaza Genocide” accusation

Dena Tauber's avatar

Thank you for that information.

Unlocking Freedom's avatar

Now we really believe the time has come for the rogue Israeli colony to be dismantled. The Israeli colony cannot be accommodated nor can it be reformed, it has to end and this is how we have to think of the future. There is no room, in the middle east, or in the world, for a state that is genocidal, that practices apartheid that commits evil, every minute of every day at the moment as we are seeing.

https://www.printernational.co.uk/timmann2/history.htm

Steve S's avatar

The "genocide" hoax leveled against Israel was always a part of the propaganda element planned prior to October 7th. The real attempted genocide that occurred on October 7th with 1200 dead, with hamas stating their intent to make everyday October 7th for Israel, would have resulted in over 1 million dead. It isn't for lack of trying that hamas hasn't come close to achieving this objective. Israel has stopped them, yet in 2.5 years of war there is not one day Israel has matched the one day death count of 1200 achieved by hamas. Why is that? Not even half that amount in one day, 600 dead. Why is the IDF with all its planes, missiles, tanks, navy, unable to kill so many in one day if they are committing genocide? We all know the answer, it is because there is no genocide.

The constant repeating of the phrases "genocide, apartheid, ethnic cleansing," all lies when attributed to Israel, are the successful portion of the hamas and Jew hating crowd. The devil spawned brain worm that causes Jew hatred has robbed otherwise intelligent people of their critical thinking ability. As the devil hated Job because despite the miseries he suffered Job still loved G-d, the devil hates the Jew because despite the miseries inflicted upon them the Jew still loves G-d. As Hashem eventually restored Job, so too will Hashem one day end the devil spawned miseries inflicted upon Jews.

Laura's avatar

If intent alone is the definition of genocide, then certainly October 7 was a genocide and the very purpose of the "palestinian" movement is genocide of Jews.

Israel's only purpose in its military operations is self-defense.

...............................................................................................................................................................................................

"Israel’s critics minimize this fact by pointing out that the legal definition of genocide does not explicitly require a declining population. Under the Genocide Convention, the central question is intent to destroy a protected group, not demographic outcomes".

Vincent Bocchinfuso's avatar

Ask one person online screaming "Genocide!" to define "dolus specialis" without looking it up. Sickening.

https://vincentbocchinfuso.substack.com/p/genocide?r=hc6i0